| Name | Hometown | Specialty | Challenge! |
| Jason Wain | Marlboro, NJ | high-arcing single bounce | Challenge! |
| Jamie Carlson | Wethersfield, CT | All-around player (singles, doubles, and occasionally triples - no quads) | Challenge! |
| Brendan Houle | Monroe Twp, NJ | Inconsistent throws, but consistent results (losing). | Challenge! |
| Cameron | Jacksonville FL | Spectating | Challenge! |
| Paul (Fergie) | Burtonsville, MD | Laser Rocket Single Shot | Challenge! |
| Kinney | Unknown | Perfect Spiral Every Time | Challenge! |
| Mitch | Twin Cities | BBQ Chicken | Challenge! |
| Mealticket | Seattle | Primarily (called shot) doubles with a sprinkle of Jedi mind tricks, defense and beta blockers | Challenge! |
| Deuce | New Orleans, Louisiana | Making Moaks' mom happy with a suit | Challenge! |
| Jesse | New Britain, CT | Calzone Champ | Challenge! |
| Gabe Gajecki | wolcott | jack of all trades | Challenge! |
| JD | Columbia, MO | "Fly-fishing" delivery | Challenge! |
| AP | Green Bay, WI | Virtual wall in Gator | Challenge! |
| Manole Pelarinos | Newington | | Challenge! |
| Kaitlin | Atlanta, GA | steel trap memory | Challenge! |
| Bryan Wain | Marlboro, NJ | carbo loading | Challenge! |
| Andrew Feldman | Highland Mills, NY | Triples or More | Challenge! |
| Austin Hamilton | Scottsdale, AZ | flushing | Challenge! |
| Jodie St. John | Milton, Ontario (CA) | Stanley Funnels | Challenge! |
| Keith Lam | Memphis | | Challenge! |
| Blood Diamond | Philly | ball lubrication | Challenge! |
| Mike Polikoff | Chicago | Template Author | Challenge! |
| Fish | Butler, PA | Singles | Challenge! |
| Brian Jackson | New Milford, CT | I'm a n00b, still finding my specialty | Challenge! |
| Pepe Ortiz | San Juan, PR | to be discovered! | Challenge! |
| Diego | | | Challenge! |
| Brad Lage | Warwick, RI | bourbon | Challenge! |
| Henry | Seattle | Single Shot Sniper | Challenge! |
| Tyler | Seattle | Double bounce | Challenge! |
| Marcus Sacco | Seattle, WA | | Challenge! |
| Janny | | | Challenge! |
| Nicole '"rim" sarsfield | sarsfield | deucein' | Challenge! |
